Three-Act Structure vs. Organic Storytelling

Three-act structure creates reader expectations, then fulfills or subverts them. Act breaks aren’t arbitrary—they mark psychological shifts in how readers engage with the story.

• Why it worksStructure manages pacing and emotional escalation. In The Hunger Games, Suzanne Collins uses classic three-act beats: Katniss volunteers (inciting incident), enters the arena (end of Act One), forms alliance with Rue (midpoint complication), Rue dies (midpoint shift), rule change announced (Act Two climax), berries (climax). Each beat raises stakes and narrows options. Readers feel the tightening vice.
• How to do itMap your major turning points, then fill the space between them organically. In Six of Crows, Leigh Bardugo structures the heist with clear act breaks—recruitment, infiltration, betrayal, escape—but lets character dynamics develop naturally within those sections. Structure holds the frame. Character fills the interior.

Organic storytelling shines in scenes where characters surprise even the writer. These moments feel alive because they emerge from personality, not plot necessity.

• Why it worksCharacter-driven scenes create authenticity. In The Fault in Our Stars, John Green’s best moments come from Hazel and Augustus talking—conversations that meander, joke, philosophize. The cancer plot provides structure. The relationship develops organically through dialogue that sounds like real teenagers, not exposition machines.
• How to do itWrite scenes where characters pursue their immediate desires without worrying about hitting plot points. In Red, White & Royal Blue, Casey McQuiston lets Alex and Henry’s text exchanges unfold naturally. The political plot provides framework, but their banter develops through organic riffing on each other’s personalities.

In Salt & Bone, Jack and Lisa’s relationship develops through small, organic moments that don’t serve plot function:

The kitchen smelled like burnt toast and something sweet under it—peaches, maybe. I’d just fixed the toaster the day before. Or thought I had.

Lisa stood by the window, holding a mug with both hands like she needed the weight of it to stay anchored.

I leaned against the counter. One leg up, ankle hooked behind the opposite knee. Trying not to look like I was watching her.

Trying and failing.

The outbreak provides structure. Their connection emerges organically through observation and silence.

The midpoint isn’t just “middle of the story.” It shifts the protagonist’s understanding of what they’re actually fighting for.

• Why it worksMidpoint reversals reframe everything that came before. In The Fifth Season, N.K. Jemisin uses the midpoint to reveal Essun’s daughter might still be alive. This changes the story from grief journey to rescue mission. Same character, same world, different stakes.
• How to do itIntroduce information at the midpoint that forces the protagonist to reconsider their goal or methods. In Throne of Glass, Sarah J. Maas uses the midpoint reveal about the king’s plans to shift Celaena from “win the competition” to “survive the king’s machinations.”

Subplots don’t need the same structural rigidity as the main plot. They can wander, pause, resurface. This creates texture.

• Why it worksOrganic subplots feel like life happening alongside the main story. In The Name of the Wind, Patrick Rothfuss lets Kvothe’s relationships with Denna, Auri, and his music develop in fits and starts. They don’t follow neat arcs—they pulse through the narrative naturally.
• How to do itIntroduce subplot threads, then let them surface when character interaction makes them relevant again. In Gideon the Ninth, Tamsyn Muir allows the relationships between different Houses to develop organically through proximity and conflict, not through structured romance beats.

In The Death of Me, Katie’s friendship with Sherry and her relationship with Martin don’t follow parallel arcs—they develop based on Katie’s emotional state and available time:

“Sorry I acted that way today.” He draped his arm around my shoulders when I sat next to him, so I leaned into it, resting my cheek on the chest of his shirt.

“What was that about, anyway?”

“Nothing.”

“Bull,” I said. “That wasn’t nothing. Something’s been bothering you. What’s thinkin’?”

The thirty-day deadline provides structure. The relationships develop through genuine emotional need.

Sometimes the story requires breaking structural rules. Character logic might demand a quiet scene where structure demands action.

• Why it worksBreaking structure creates surprise. In Station Eleven, Emily St. John Mandel jumps between timelines and perspectives in ways that violate traditional structure. The fractured approach mirrors the fractured post-apocalyptic world. Form follows function.
• How to do itIdentify where rigid structure conflicts with character truth, then choose character. In The Song of Achilles, Madeline Miller doesn’t structure Patroclus and Achilles’s relationship around typical romance beats—their love develops gradually, without declaration scenes or manufactured conflict.

Structure ensures readers feel rising tension. Organic discovery ensures characters sound like themselves, not like plot devices.

• Why it worksCombining both creates stories that satisfy structurally while feeling alive. In We Are the Ants, Shaun David Hutchinson uses structured countdown (160 days until Earth’s destruction) alongside Henry’s messy, organic process of deciding whether saving the world matters.
• How to do itOutline major turning points for pacing, then write scenes in character voice without worrying about hitting every beat perfectly. Revision can tighten structure. First drafts should chase character truth.

Knowing where the story ends prevents aimless wandering. Discovering how characters get there keeps the journey surprising.

• Why it worksPlanned endings provide direction without dictating every step. In Code Name Verity, Elizabeth Wein knew the ending’s emotional punch but discovered the path through character voice and historical detail. The structure held tension. The writing created heartbreak.
• How to do itEstablish your ending’s emotional and plot resolution, then write toward it without rigidly plotting every scene. In The Poet X, Elizabeth Acevedo knew Xiomara would find her voice through poetry, but the specific poems and confrontations emerged organically during writing.

In Salt & Bone, I knew Jack and Lisa would end up together, but the specific moments that built their connection emerged through writing:

He whispered things into my skin that I didn’t deserve.

And I let him.

Afterward, he lay tangled with me beneath the blanket. Our legs overlapped. His breath slowed beside me, his hand resting over the curve of my hip.

“Where have you been all my life?” I asked softly.

He chuckled. “Apparently in the same town as you.”

The structural endpoint (relationship) was planned. The emotional texture was discovered.

First drafts chase organic truth. Revision imposes structure on what you discovered.

• Why it worksSeparating drafting from structuring frees writers to follow character logic initially, then tighten pacing later. In Bird by Bird, Anne Lamott advocates for “shitty first drafts” that prioritize discovery over perfection. Structure comes in revision.
• How to do itWrite scenes that excite you, in whatever order they arrive. Later, assess whether they build tension and progress the plot. Cut what doesn’t serve both character and structure.

Three-act structure provides scaffolding that keeps stories from collapsing under their own weight. Organic storytelling creates moments that feel discovered rather than constructed. The best narratives use structure to manage reader expectations and pacing while allowing character logic to drive scene-level choices.

Readers remember both the satisfaction of a well-structured climax and the authenticity of a character moment that surprised them. Structure ensures they reach the end. Organic writing ensures they care about getting there.

That’s when story structure becomes invisible—and that’s when it works best.

• Read about Salt & Bone
• Read about The Death of Me
• Sign up for the newsletter to get weekly tips
• The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins
• Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo
• The Fault in Our Stars by John Green
• Red, White & Royal Blue by Casey McQuiston
• The Fifth Season by N.K. Jemisin
• Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas
• The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss
• Gideon the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir
• Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel
• The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller
• We Are the Ants by Shaun David Hutchinson
• Code Name Verity by Elizabeth Wein
• The Poet X by Elizabeth Acevedo
• Bird by Bird by Anne Lamott